Oct. 18, 2011, marked a significant day in Israeli history as Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit was released from captivity in Gaza after being kidnapped by Hamas terrorists five years earlier. In a symbolic moment, Shalit was photographed in uniform saluting Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, showcasing the success of a dedicated protest movement led by his determined parents.
Reflecting on the Israel-Hamas ceasefire deal announced recently, Israeli politician Einat Wilf recalled the exchange that took place during Shalit’s release. In return for Shalit’s freedom, Israel released 1,027 Palestinian security prisoners, including Yahya Sinwar, who later orchestrated an attack in 2023.
Wilf expressed concerns about the potential consequences of releasing convicted terrorists, as Israel is set to release over 1,000 Palestinians imprisoned for terrorism in exchange for the hostages held by Hamas. While many Israelis support the ceasefire deal to end the Israel-Hamas war and secure the release of hostages, there is widespread unease about the release of potentially dangerous individuals.
Despite reservations, supporters of the agreement acknowledge the necessity of making concessions to secure the return of hostages. Polls have consistently shown that a majority of Israelis favor a deal to end the conflict, even though it involves releasing Palestinian security prisoners who may pose a threat in the future.
Israel has previously released Palestinian prisoners as part of negotiations with various groups, including during past peace talks and ceasefire agreements. Critics of the current deal argue for a more decisive stance against Hamas and express concerns about the potential risks of releasing individuals who could engage in further violence against Israel.
While some families of hostages oppose the agreement, citing fears of future attacks and kidnappings, others emphasize the importance of prioritizing the safe return of all captives. Advocates for Israel abroad also approach the deal with caution, acknowledging the challenges posed by the release of Palestinian prisoners with violent backgrounds.
Gershon Baskin, a key figure in brokering the Shalit deal, described the current agreement as imperfect but necessary. He expressed hope that the release of security prisoners would not result in further violence and emphasized the importance of preventing future conflicts.
Keep Jewish Stories in Focus.
JTA has documented Jewish history in real-time for over a century. Keep our journalism strong by joining us in supporting independent, award-winning reporting.